Rail Timetable

For many months, Sir Oliver has been pressing for further information and for changes to the proposed timetables covering stations within his constituency, particularly fast services to and from London in the peak.  He has met with Govia on several occasions and has discussed his concerns with the Rail Minister. Sir Oliver has been working closely with Rail Users’ Groups, who have been having detailed discussions with Govia representatives.

4 December 2018 -  Transport Select Committee report: GTR response attached below.

22 November 2018 - Joint update on the winter timetable from GTR and Network Rail attached below.

14 November 2018 - I met the Chairman of the Office of Rail and Road (ORR), Professor Stephen Glaister, to discuss the recent rail timetable chaos which has led to passengers enduring delays, cancellations and uncertainty about their journeys.

Professor Glaister published an interim enquiry report into the May timetable chaos on 20 September and is finalising his main report. I pressed for improved co-ordination between Network Rail and the rail operator and also that there should be much better planning for major changes on the railways. I suggested that the sort of Delivery Body used in the Olympics preparations might be a good model. Professor Glaister and his team also outlined their approach to the issues and explained that the final report would set out their concerns.

I was glad to have the opportunity to make these points at the highest level in the enquiry.

29 October 2018 - Details of Govia and Network Rail's winter timetable have been released to stakeholders (see attachment below).

26 October 2018 - Good news from GTR’s latest In-touch:' Passengers given first glimpse of new trains set to transform Great Northern suburban service.' (Details in the attachment below). Following up on constituents’ concerns, I asked when these trains are coming on our routes and was told GTR will be introducing them later this year with the full fleet introduced for spring 2019.

16 October 2018 - Department of Transport's 'root and branch' review of the rail industry has been published. See Secretary of State's letter attached.

15 October 2018 - This week's joint update from GTR and Network Rail is attached below.

20 September 2018 - The Glaister review into the rail chaos came out today and here is the link. Our line has suffered very badly and this confirms that there has not been proper co-ordination.

The Secretary of State, Chris Grayling MP, has today announced a wide ranging review into the way the rail industry works and his letter to MPs is attached below.  I have called for no fare increases while the service is inadequate and I will continue to press the case.

12 September 2018 - Latest meeting with Govia and Network Rail (see attachment below).

3 September 2018 - Letter from the CEO (see attachment below).

29 August 2018 - I joined other local MPs in signing a letter to Chris Grayling asking for a fare freeze until GTR meets its contractual obligations for passengers by operating a service that achieves set reliability standards for at least 3 months (see attachment below).

28 August 2018 - GTR extends industry compensation scheme to non-season ticket holders on Thameslink and Great Northern. See attached update.

15 August 2018 - I have received the attached performance update from Thameslink and Great Northern.

14 August 2018 - I have today written to the Transport Secretary, Chris Grayling, opposing any rail fare increase in the New Year in the light of the dreadful service on our line.

14 August 2018 - Letter from Jo Johnson to the Letchworth Rail Users Group (see attachment below)

13 August 2018 - Sir Oliver has taken up further concerns from constituents with Passenger Service Director, Stuart Cheshire.

6 August 2018 - I have attached a joint update from Govia Thameslink Railway and Network Rail with a progress update on the new timetable from 15 July.

1 August 2018 - I have received this performance update from Govia.

Below are the latest performance figures available for the first two weeks that the interim timetable has been in operation, compared with the two weeks prior to that. 

                                                    Thameslink             Great Northern                        Combined Thameslink and Great Northern


2 July – 13 July (Mon-Fri)               59.25%                     62.45%                                               60.6%

16 July – 27 July (Mon-Fri)             76.15%                     77.95%                                               76.85%

PPM is the Public Performance Measure – the percentage of all trains arriving within five minutes of their booked time.

We are running around 200 more services per day across the network compared to the period before the May changeover, providing extra journey options.

Overall, the train service has been more stable and reliable with almost 77% of Thameslink and Great Northern services arriving on time, compared with 61% in the previous two weeks.

There has been disruption to services over this period largely caused by a number of significant infrastructure issues, unrelated to the timetable. Below are examples of the most disruptive individual incidents since 15 July. 

For example, on Thameslink, a tree on the overhead power lines at St Albans on Friday 20 July caused a third of Thameslink services to be delayed (by over 30 hours in total) or cancelled (over 100 cancellations). A signal failure near Norwood Junction on 26 July caused 24 hours of delay.  On Great Northern, a failure of the overhead power lines at Cambridge on 23 July resulted in 13 hours of delay and over 60 cancellations. Track defects at Cuffley and Hertford North caused over 30 hours of delays and 20 cancellations across 23 and 24 July.

We will continue our focus on improving the performance of the service further in the coming weeks and looking ahead, we will start restoring the remaining ‘May’ services to the timetable as soon as practicably possible.

30 July 2018 - I have written to the Rail Minister today about the bad start to week three of the interim timetable.

25 July 2018 - I am pressing for up to date information on the stability and reliability of the new interim timetable.  I am told by many passengers that there has been an improvement in reliability from GTR but I am asking for detailed statistics, so that we can judge the overall picture.  Commenting, Sir Oliver said “GTR are now in last chance saloon and it is important that we see real progress in establishing reliability.”

24 July 2018 - Sir Oliver has written to Jo Johnson asking what progress has been made in compensation for carnet rail passengers and regular travellers.  Commenting, Sir Oliver Heald said “Many travellers in our area are not season ticket holders but regularly travel three or four days a week.  They have suffered the misery of the last two months and I am looking for them to be compensated too.

24 July 2018 - Sir Oliver has today written to the senior Network Rail official for our area asking for an explanation for the infrastructure failings on our line.  These have included problems with signalling, overhead wires and points.  Commenting, Sir Oliver said “It is very frustrating that as GTR are desperately trying to stabilise the service, we have had this spate of infrastructure failings.  I am asking for a full explanation.

20 July 2018 - Here is a summary by Leanne Stott of the Letchworth Rail users Group of the meeting at Brotherhood Hall yesterday.  This was a very constructive meeting.

Thank you to all who attended last night, that was a powerful voice we raised and was fully acknowledged as received by Govia. Again huge apologies to those who couldn’t enter the venue, the attendance was incredible and noted for future meetings.

Alex Snelling from the Royston committee created a thorough transcript https://m.facebook.com/groups/letchworthrailusers/#!/groups/796036213896425?view=permalink&id=998198617013516
and here are the key points moving forward.

Structurally the May timetable is set and it is not possible to revert to the old one due to the interactions across the UK network with other operators.

We have made extensive representations since last summer, achieving some not insignificant changes to the May timetable and have collated all your feedback on behalf of Letchworth, Royston and Ashwell since this Spring. These have been shared in regular meetings with Govia and in dialogue with our Mps Sir Oliver Heald and Heidi Allen. We have also taken these further, where appropriate, to the Department of Transport.

Path forward:
As many have read in the press and as Scott Brightwell (Govia Operations) explained last night, there has been a nationwide freeze on 8 train operators making any amendments to the December timetable given the disaster of the 'big bang’ change as was the case with the ‘May’ timetable and its subsequent collapse. However we have achieved a remarkable goal with Govia recognising our representations and a package has been presented for inclusion in December. We have by no means had that written in stone yet, nor will we rest in pushing for further amendments and will be doing everything we can to drive this through to fruition.

The reality is that May 2019 will be the next opportunity for changes to the timetable. Those we don’t achieve for December we will do everything to achieve then. Another key point is ensuring the second hourly Thameslink train is delivered, this provides considerable capacity and without it we are going to experience over-crowding at Royston and Letchworth during key peaks.

Beyond this, in the much longer term, there is a need to look at how the Great Northern route sits within the wider UK network. Lynne and Gary from the Letchworth committee will be driving this forward with the goal of greater allocation of train paths and resources for the benefit of the whole of north Hertfordshire.

To briefly touch on compensation, as you know there is currently compensation being made available to season ticket holders; there is a broader drive by many RUGs on our line (and particularly championed by Sir Oliver) for carnet and other ticket holders to also receive part of the compensation packet.

A huge thank you to the following people who work within the RUGs and those who helped make last night such a powerful message.
Sir Oliver Heald who has been in almost daily contract with us monitoring the situation and making regular representations in Parliament.
Councillor Helen Oliver who Chaired last night flawlessly and with humour.
Martin Phillips for printing hundreds of flyers.
Will Bryan for designing the flyers
NHDC for generously providing a venue and Letchworth Councillor Gary Grindal for supporting that.
Our fabulous LRUG committee Steve McMullen, Lynne Ceeneyy, Gary Bell, Catherine Halpern Dock, Hilary Kemp, Rachel Morris, Denise Light who all went above and beyond getting the word out and continue to work on the longer term for the future of our services.
Royston committee member in attendance last night Alex Snelling and his wonderful transcript.
The Chairs of Ashwell Sarah and Lee with whom we’ve done so much work presenting joint practical solutions to Govia.
And those at Govia who have heard our representations and been constructively working with us to find a solution. Scott deserves credit for standing up there last night and answering all our questions, even when they were answers we didn't want to hear.
There are many more who take the time to speak to the media, talk with local businesses and groups about our work, post useful information to the page, keep the mood upbeat with humour and a thank you to all of you contributing whenever you can.

We should be proud of our communities in tackling this pro-actively and constructively. We promise as RUGs we will use that energy to continue to press forward and keep you updated on progress/ news.

18 July 2018 - Emergency debate on Govia - Urgent Question

See my contribution to the debate at https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2018-07-18/debates/9DC16B02-43F6-4698-B229-DEFE7E3861D1/GoviaThameslinkFranchise

18 July 2018MPs call on Govia to deliver the step change they promised

The Rt Hon Sir Oliver Heald, MP for North East Hertfordshire, and Stephen McPartland, MP for Stevenage, have met Rail Ministers again this week to keep the pressure on Govia.

They understand the frustrations of passengers as they also depend on the services, which have just not been good enough. 

Stephen McPartland, Member of Parliament for Stevenage said, “Enough is enough, the latest timetable must stabilise this week and deliver the step change in reliability we were promised. Local people have run out of patience with Govia and we made that clear again today to the Secretary of State and the Rail Minister. 

Our focus is on ensuring that once the timetable is stabilised the increases in services we expected back in May, are delivered in a carefully planned manner. The improvements for Stevenage and Knebworth are immense, with many more trains, thousands more seats and new destinations.”

“I have tried to get the best service for my constituents and there have been a number of additional services we have been able to introduce for both Knebworth and Stevenage over the last few weeks. However, I will not be satisfied until we have all the benefits of the new timetable for both of my stations.”

Rt Hon Sir Oliver Heald MP, said, “Govia are on their final chance. The new timetable must stabilise the service or I will call for the franchise to be withdrawn. I am monitoring performance very carefully this week.”

17 July 2018 - Chris Grayling replies to RUG's ongoing concerns. (See attachment below).

16 July 2018 - On the first full day of the new timetable it was disappointing that there were early morning delays and cancellations on the Govia Northern line. I immediately spoke to Jo Johnson, Rail Minister, emphasising that Govia Thameslink are in the last chance saloon and that if the new timetable is not stable within a week I will be calling for an end to the franchise.

11 July 2018 - Received a letter from Stuart Cheshire, Passenger Service Director for Thameslink / Great Northern about July 15 timetable. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/gtr-message-about-july-15-timetable

Attended briefing with Nick Brown, COO of GTR, and John Halsall of Network Rail. Also met Stuart Cheshire, GTR Passenger Services Director. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/update-rail-meetings

10 July 2018 - Continuing to take up passenger’s concerns. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mp-piles-more-pressure-gtr

5 July 2018 - Received letter from Chris Grayling about compensation. (See attachment below).

4 July 2018 - Sir Oliver questions Prime Minister during PMQs about rail chaos. You can watch the clip of Oliver's question here: https://parliamentlive.tv/event/index/1ce1d9b9-6dff-4109-b07c-f3372d21da95

3 July 2018 - Pressed Jo Johnson in the Chamber of the House of Commons about the rail situation. Later met Chris Grayling and raised Health & Safety concerns about overcrowding, the need for an early compensation announcement and the need for evening flyers to stop at Letchworth.

2 July 2018 - Wrote to the Transport Secretary (See attachment below).

29 June 2018 - Sir Oliver has welcomed the Rail Minister’s response to his call for First Class to be suspended until 15 July. Received letter from the Minister, Jo Johnson MP (See attachment below)

28 June 2018- Met Chris Grayling with neighbouring MPs to discuss the chaos on our railway. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mp-has-more-talks-secretary-state

27 June 2018 - Spoke to Chris Grayling at 8 o'clock this morning to reinforce that service is still unacceptable. He will press GTR at a meeting later today. I have written with colleagues Heidi Allen and Johnathan Djanogly to GTR putting forward strong concerns (See attachment below)

25 June 2018 - Working closely with the RUG and have immediately followed up their concerns by writing to Chris Grayling MP and Stuart Cheshire at GTR. I have also received from Nick Brown at GTR (See attachment below)

20 June 2018 - Met senior GTR officials this morning including Passenger Services Director Stuart Cheshire and Deputy CEO Alex Foulds. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/20-june-meeting-senior-gtr-officials

19 June 2018 - Oliver continues to press Ministers over rail reliability. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/oliver-continues-press-ministers-over-rail-reliability

12 June 2018 - Spoke yesterday to the Rail Minister, Jo Johnson, about the continuing unreliability on our line. He and Chris Grayling took up the concerns with Govia in a meeting yesterday afternoon.

4 June 2018 -Met again with the Passenger Services Director for Govia, Stuart Cheshire. Govia would be advertising an interim timetable on the various rail websites and all advertised services will run (barring unforeseen circumstances such as last minute driver illness). In addition, extra services will be introduced to the interim timetable as more drivers finish their route training.

Held frank meeting with Secretary of State Chris Grayling to ask him to put pressure on GTR and pressed for proper passenger compensation. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mp-demands-action-transport-secretary

Statement to the House of Commons by Chris Grayling MP, Secretary of State for Transport. https://www.parliament.uk/business/news/2018/june/statement-on-rail-timetabling-4-june-2018/

11 June 2018 - MP's discussion with CEO of Govia Thameslink https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mps-discussion-ceo-govia-thameslink

Had frank discussion with Charles Horton about unacceptable situation at the beginning of week 4 and in particular the absolute need for accurate information and reliable service during peak periods. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mps-discussion-ceo-govia-thameslink

31 May 2018 -Received this joint media statement from Network Rail, GTR and Northern: ttps://www.northernrailway.co.uk/news/latest-news/1878-joint-statement-from-network-rail-gtr-and-northern

29 May 2018 - Received letter from the Rt Hon Chris Grayling MP about the timetable (See attachment below)

23 May 2018 - Remarks by the Secretary of State for Transport, Chris Grayling, in the House this afternoon, in a debate about services in the North.  He lays much of the blame for this week’s problems at the door of Network Rail. 

"What we have seen in the last few days has not been good enough. No one should underestimate the logistical challenge of introducing a timetable change. The changes have been made for a very good reason: they mean a big expansion of services across the country. A timetable change of such a scale involves reorganising staff rotas, training staff for new routes, and reorganising how we deploy our trains. It needed months of preparation, and I am afraid that a number of things went wrong, but most particularly the fact that for the second time in six months, Network Rail was far too late in finalising planned timetable changes and left the rest of the industry struggling to catch up. I am not happy with that at all and I have told the leadership of Network Rail that it cannot happen again.

"I know that many passengers have had disrupted journeys; that is not good enough. I am sorry that that was the case, and everyone in my Department and people elsewhere are working hard to get the problem sorted out. But this has been a major teething problem in what will be a step forward for the railways."

20 May 2018 - The new timetables were introduced on 20 May 2018 and will be subject to further adjustment in December 2018.

22 May 2018 - Called in Stuart Cheshire, Passenger Services Director for Govia, to the House of Commons. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mp-calls-top-govia-executive-explain-rail-chaos

Received statement from Katherine Cox of Govia. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/statement-katherine-cox-govia

Receiving complaints that many services are being cancelled.  He has asked for an explanation and been told by GNR that there is "a transition period".  He has complained that it was not made clear in advance that this would affect the Royston to Kings Cross/St Pancras line. Also met Stuart Cheshire, Passenger Services Director for Govia, to the House of Commons this morning.

21 May 2018 - Received complaints on the first day of the new timetable that there were no trains running from Royston to St Pancras causing inconvenience to passengers.  Immediately contacted Katherine Cox, Stakeholder Manager at Govia Thameslink Railway to ask for an explanation and to know when this will be put right. https://www.oliverheald.com/news/mp-takes-rail-complaints





Attachment Size
180529 - Chris Grayling - Dear Colleague - TSGN MPs - TSGN Rail Timetables - Final.pdf 261.31 KB
Letter from Nick Brown to MPs.pdf 289.35 KB
HA OH JD joint letter to GTR 26th June 2018.pdf 238.98 KB
Annex A to join letter to GTR - RAIL USER GROUP REPRESENTATIONS.pdf 299.83 KB
180628 - Jo Johnson - Dear Colleague MPs - Thameslink and Great Northern Rail Services.pdf 39.6 KB
180702 Joint Letter to Chris Grayling.pdf 618.15 KB
20180704 Dear Colleague Transport Secretary GTR compensation.pdf 169.7 KB
Chris Grayling 16 July reply to RUG concerns.pdf 112.88 KB
Update from Govia Thameslink Railway and Network Rail.docx 66.79 KB
Jo Johnson's letter to the Letchworth RUG.pdf 48.04 KB
Performance Data 15 August.docx 31 KB
Additional industry compensation scheme.docx 14.34 KB
Letter from the CEO 3 Sept 2018.docx 14.98 KB
Fares Freeze Letter to Chris Grayling 29 Aug 2018.pdf.docx 164.1 KB
Latest meeting with Govia and Network Rail.docx 12.54 KB
Dear Colleague Rail.pdf 1.96 MB
GTR and Network Rail joint update 12 October 2018.docx 15.69 KB
Chris Grayling - Dear Colleague all MPs - Rail Review (002).pdf 50.94 KB
Winter Timetable.docx 16.28 KB
GTR stakeholder newsletter.docx 12.63 KB
GTR and Network Rail joint update 22 November 2018.docx 17.51 KB
GTR response to Transport Select Committee report.docx 13.26 KB